Why I Switched from Public Schooling to Homeschooling

It’s time for the third post in the parent interview series about schooling a highly sensitive child. This week I talk to Tara who is in Canada. She removed her son from a funded state school in order to homeschool him instead.

Why I Switched from Public Schooling to Homeschooling

HSK: Why did you start looking at alternative schooling arrangements for you son?

Tara: My son missed a lot of school because he simply refused to go. We thought it was a physical illness so we had a bunch of tests done to try and figure out what it was. All tests came back negative so we realised it was psychological.

At this point we reached out to the principle and teacher and arranged a meeting. David was banging his head when I tried to get him to go to school; the principle said once self-harm is evident we have to pull back and offer alternatives.

Why I Switched from Public Schooling to Homeschooling

Resource Tip for Homeschoolers – 1 to 6 May 2019 Only

Here are some great resources to help you on your homeschooling journey. This homeschool bundle is just a small part of the Ultimate Homemaking Bundle 2019. 

  • Digital Homeschool Convention Sessions (Summit)
  • Five Senses Letter-a-Week Activity Guide (eBook: opportunities for multi-sensory exploration all across the curriculum).
  • Home Management for the Homeschool Mom (Audiobook)
  • Homeschooling with Confidence (Workbook)
  • How Do You Want Your Homeschool to Feel Audio / Workbook

Homeschooling Resource

  • Science in the Kitchen: Fearless Science at Home For All Ages eBook
  • Student Planner Bundle Printable
  • Teach Your Children “How to Think” with Mentoring eBook 
  • Tracing Fun Mega Bundle: Fine Motor Skill Fun for Kids (Printable)

HSK: What support did you get from school to find solutions to help him with his anxiety? Did the school understand the idea of highly sensitive and the implications of that in a classroom?

Tara: We didn’t have much support from the school except a meeting after he’d missed a lot of school to talk about a plan.

The principle brought up the term highly empathetic but I brought in the HSC book to show them (HSK: Elaine Aron’s The Highly Sensitive Child – UK link here).

However, the message back was that he should learn skills to cope in that environment because life is like that. I agreed, but said it doesn’t have to be when he is 6 years old. One thing about school they can’t change is the size. There were over 800 kids in that school and 25 in his class; it was too much for him.

HSK: How did you arrive at the decision to homeschool?

Tara: Because of the self-harming. Homeschool was offered as a viable option as we all realised that getting him back in the classroom was no longer an option. The school referred us to homeschooling through the board of education and also referred us to a school psychologist.

The idea was to give him a few sessions and then try to get him back to school for a few subjects. After 2 sessions they wanted him to try school and we felt he wasn’t ready so then he became 100% homeschooled.

He was so full of anxiety that it was our only option. He simply refused to go and was self harming at any attempt to drop him off.

HSK: What did your extended family and friends think when you chose the homeschooling route?

Tara: They were supportive as it is quite normal here to homeschool. And they saw how much happier he was. As parents we had a tough time adjusting as we were both schooled in traditional schools.

HSK: In what ways do you notice that your son is happier/less stressed since leaving school?

Tara: Telling him he didn’t have to go back to school took his stress away almost immediately . He said everyone was mean and it was too busy and loud.

We unschooled for 4-6 weeks to let him rest and come down after such a traumatic experience.

He is a very happy kid now and a lot more confident and sure of himself. We just wrapped up the term (jan to june) and we did really well according to our facilitator. I am thankful that our board of education supports homeschooling and that I am able to stay home with him to do it.

The principle still wants him to return as a new school is opening in our area which will be smaller but we aren’t convinced this is the best route, we will see. In the meantime David continues to see a psychologist for play therapy to work on ways to deal with his anxiety and stress.

Schooling and the Highly Sensitive Child Interview Series: Why I Switched from Public Schooling to Homeschooling

Lessons from Tara’s Story

  • It’s natural for parents to want to school their children in the way they themselves were schooled. Looking beyond our own experiences can reap great rewards.
  • Sometimes you need to stand up for your child and fight to protect their best interests – you may not have school on your side.
  • Many teachers, heads and boards of schools do not understand what highly sensitive is nor the adverse effect a busy noisy classroom can have on a HSC. Many parents find themselves trying to educate the educators about their HSC.
  • A schooling solution can also be a temporary solution. Tara has kept their options open to suit the needs of her child. Don’t close doors.

Read More

Schooling and the Highly Sensitive Child Interview Series: Why I Decided to Homeschool


About Amanda van Mulligen

Mother, writer, author, blogger. Born British, Living Dutch. I have three Dutch sons and a Dutch husband and I blog about Turning Dutch and raising highly sensitive children.
This entry was posted in The How and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Why I Switched from Public Schooling to Homeschooling

  1. Rachael says:

    Thankyou so much for this detailed sharing.
    My son is not stereotypical HS but I am sure he follows many traits.
    When I read this I see you as a mother being incredibly brave on your child’s behalf for making the decision to home school. It must have been so difficult. I have often battled with this same question.lof homeschooling. When I have suggested it I am met with people telling me he wouldn’t learn to socialise, that it’s not in his best interest given that we all have to get on in adult life. But as you say he is only 6. Why not comfort and provide safe gentle learning space now. Why must they be thrust in to a clearly uncomfortable setting and forced to conform? Does it really help them?
    You have given me much food for thought
    Thankyou again
    Best wishes to you and yours


  2. Rhonda Steel says:

    Thank you for this article. My son has the same situation continuously from pre-school through 4th grade when I took him out for homeschooling. He did have great teachers, but despite all their efforts the nature of public school is naturally overstimulating and my son reacted in a text book HSC ways. I am at a loss at this point. He would like to go back to school, but on registering him for a school he believes he likes, not realizing himself, his anxiety has begun to raise. He was avoiding eye contact when introduced, becoming angered and then melting down and crying about an random unrelated concerns in the car and not sitting still in a chair at the registrar office. I honestly am at a lost as to what to do with him.


  3. Pingback: How to Help Your Highly Sensitive Child Back to School After the Summer Break | Happy Sensitive Kids

  4. nakimum says:

    Thank so much for this. I always knew our daughter was a very sensitive soul and it was fine, until we hit the school years and things just went downhill. She really tried to make it work, she tried so very hard for 3 years until I couldn’t take the battles and less-than-positive support from the school anymore. Started homeschooling around the end of 2014 and have not looked back.
    I am not saying all schools and teachers are bad, we were just unlucky. Thanks to posts like this, I am slowly learning to work with, work through situations and to understand my daughter and her feelings.


  5. Tara says:

    Thanks Amanda, I love that our story may help others.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.